Greenvoe … a review


I picked up this book because it was the only one I found that was by George Mackay Brown. I wanted to read something by him because he’s called The Bard of Orkney and I wanted to read something that was set in the islands and so I got this book and the South Uist one. Anyway, I read this first. It is about the tight-knit community on the Orcadian island of Hellya, where residents are trying to come to terms with the destruction weilded by Operation Black Star, a military project that needs the island for some unknown purpose.

Now, while as a story it is well-written, with a nice poetic prose language. The narrative spans a week in the life of the islanders – everyone from school going children to boatmen. Most of the book is about the day to day lives of these people, what they do, what they think, how they talk etc. However, I was not very intensely moved by the book. I kept getting mixed up with all the characters, I thought there were too many of them.

I was able to keep reading because every now and then, I’d come to a sub-plot, about dark secrets or growing up, and I’d be engrossed for the next 30 pages or so. But then I’d be left confused for another while until the next good sub-plot came along. So while it had lovely language, it did not have enough cohesiveness in the plot for me. And so, it was probably a bad book by the author to have picked up as a first read.

Have any of you read anything else by him? Any recommendations?


4 thoughts on “Greenvoe … a review

      • Well there are quite a few volumes, and it’s been a while since I read them. Obviously all the stories are set in the islands, over varying time spans so I cannot recall a particular one above others. There was A Time To Keep, and Hawkfall. Also Winter Tales, which is convenient for the time of year. If you want to try another novel, his last Beside The Ocean Of Time was short listed for the Booker Prize.
        I love Orkney and am familiar with some of the places he writes about, and so that helps when I read his stuff. Good luck-hope you discover something you like.

      • Wow, thank you so much. I have been looking for someone who knows something about the isles and can recommend for so long now. Thank you, I shall lay claim to Christmas presents! *evil laugh and scurries away*

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.